OP. I am not here to say the Aetna options (or any other options for EM healthcare in the US) are great, BUT the options are not “bad”, at least some of them are not.
If you are on the Aetna select plan you are getting a smaller network and in general lower out of pocket costs. The select plan is a lipstick-on-a-pig version of what is basically an HMO.
If you are on the POS II plan you are paying more in premiums and paying 20% of the bill up to the out of pocket max. But basically you can see almost any doctor anywhere…..there are very few doctors / facilities that do not take it.
Overall I would say it’s mediocre to slightly “good” coverage. But you cannot just say “aetna bad”. The choices are there and you somewhat get that for which you pay.