Thread regarding Wells Fargo & Co. layoffs

Spans and Layers vs "dotted line" reporting

About a year ago, there was a bunch of hubbub on this site regarding spans and layers, mainly how managers need at least 7 directs and possibly 10 in the future.

Managers with fewer than 7 directs were going to be laid off, or, have their job title changed to reflect an IC status.

But with how many "dotted line" arrangements there are in this bank, it's a wonder that the spans and layers concept even exists.

Dotted line means you essentially have two bosses, which is more (not less) complicated for everyone involved.

Project managers (as an example) direct work to people all the time without a dotted line arrangement. The idea being that if you don't do what's being asked of you by the PM, your boss will have a talk with you.

If PMs can wrangle resources, delegate work/tasks, etc., then why can't everyone else that has dotted line reports do the same without the dotted line arrangement?

I just think the dotted line thing is weird, unnecessary, and only helps the person with the dotted line reports find their next job (now that they can say "I manage!").

by
| 3884 views | | 16 replies (last ) | Reply
Post ID: @OP+1dW0xGvM

16 replies (most recent on top)

IT PM guy here.

Your manager assigns you to a project that a PM Is running.

It's not a mystery.

If your manager doesn't know you're working on a project and a PM is asking you for something, that's on you to let them know.

Dotted lines are bad, but PMs are not dotted lines in that sense.

I've never asked for a manager to have "a talk" with anyone. Sometimes someone will tell me they can't get something done and why, and I'll ask the manager for more resources.

I may or may not get those resources, everything on a project is a negotiation, balancing the company needs against resources.

All that said, there are good PMs and there are nightmares. Learning how to deal with nightmares is one of the great joys of corporate life.

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2odt+1dW0xGvM

PMs exist at every company, dude. And spans and layers is kind of pointless when the new ICs still manage their teams (including hiring and writing reviews/setting comp) through the new “boss”.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2ynp+1dW0xGvM

Reorgs are stilll happening. There will be more flattening or the org structures. Dotted line reporting is painful for the “lower” boxes since two “leaders” seldom have the same agenda.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1vaw+1dW0xGvM

Charlie is off of his game. Historically, this is when he jumps to the next su---r organization. He never did get traction here with his plans to cut and being a one trick pony, I’ll give him to March.

Study his past, you’ll see. When the going gets tough, the Schlough gets going.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1sns+1dW0xGvM

I heard tech is affected

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1glf+1dW0xGvM

And then there are the "Virtual" dotted lines to Scrum Masters (or "Scrum-bags" as we call them).

Lot of IC's have multiple bosses.

Sometimes I get frustrated and say "you three managers fight it out".

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1sot+1dW0xGvM

You can go 3 down from Chuck in MN's world and see scores of examples of managers with 2 or 3 directs. There was some movement on this last year (including my team which was consolidated and 4 booted) but then, poof, seems to have stopped.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1hwc+1dW0xGvM

So my boss has less than 7 reports. Is my boss soon to be kicked out?

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1npq+1dW0xGvM

IC who was never a mgr but got dotted line directs in a reorg last year (can be seen in Teamworks). It's a manager in every way except having access to Staff Management.

Day to day management, reviews, comp planning, performance plans - yep, I do it all in templates, send to my direct mgr and they copy/paste it into whatever system it goes in.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1wgo+1dW0xGvM

Let’s call it the Wells Fargo Shuffle. It will all start all over again from square one when Charlie leaves in the next year or so. This is our future if we choose to stay. Just smile and say “Thank you sir. May I have another?”

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @ydd+1dW0xGvM

Before spans and layers, I had a boss with three directs. After spans and layers, I got a different boss, who went from three directs to 10. Additionally, I became a dotted line to both my old boss (who became an IC) and another IC. Total cluster.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @tmp+1dW0xGvM

I don’t know who MV is, but there is a lot of re-orging coming up in Q1. Our group went through this a couple months ago. Hire new manager(s). They have limited reports, making everyone scratch their head. Then re-orgs come around and then they hire more people to report to the new manager. If they are snr manager, expect a bunch of managers to move under them, cut a few of them, keep who they think are the good ones and start juggling staff around.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @uos+1dW0xGvM

Spans and layers is indeed enforced, but in practice the managers who were moved to IC roles are still managing their teams like before.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @tyk+1dW0xGvM

MV has opened up more manager positions and filled them. Most of those managers don't have seven directs. One has two directs. LOL! It's all a joke. I still can't believe anyone in their right mind would work for the one manager that has two directs.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @hdb+1dW0xGvM

Finally, somone who gets it about PMs

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @rjd+1dW0xGvM

Spans and layers does exist and is being enforced. Minimum of 7 direct reports. Some lines of business may have higher than that. If you are a manager and have less - be prepared for more, or be prepared to be gone.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @tsk+1dW0xGvM

Post a reply

: