Hydrogen 'twice as powerful a greenhouse gas as thought before': UK government study
Landmark report from Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy highlights importance of preventing leakage from future H2 infrastructure
8 April 2022 14:43 GMT UPDATED 8 April 2022 18:34 GMT
By Leigh Collins
A study released on Friday by the UK government’s Department of Business, Energy, and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) has found that hydrogen is twice as powerful a greenhouse gas as previously thought.
The 75-page report, Atmospheric Implications of Increased Hydrogen Use, explains that H2 is an indirect greenhouse gas, which reacts with other greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to increase their global warming potential (GWP).
“While hydrogen-induced changes in methane and ozone in the troposphere [the lowest layer of the atmosphere] have been considered previously, we have also considered, for the first time, previously ignored changes in stratospheric [that is, in the second-lowest layer of the atmosphere] water vapor and stratospheric ozone in our calculations of hydrogen’s GWP,” explain the authors, scientists from the National Centre for Atmospheric Sciences and the universities of Cambridge and Reading.
“We estimate the hydrogen GWP (100) [that is, over a 100-year period] to be 11 ± 5; a value more than 100% larger than previously published calculations.”
In other words, the study says the GWP figure is somewhere between six and 16, with 11 being the average — whereas the GWP of CO2 is one. A previous study from 2001, which has been frequently cited ever since, put the GWP of hydrogen at 5.8.
The report, which was commissioned by BEIS, continues: “The majority of uncertainty in the GWP arises from uncertainty regarding the natural budget of atmospheric hydrogen, where the magnitude of the soil sink for hydrogen is the most uncertain factor. Future work is required to resolve these atmospheric uncertainties.”
This all means that leaks from hydrogen pipes and equipment must be kept to a minimum.
“Any leakage of H2 will result in an indirect global warming, offsetting greenhouse gas emission reductions made as a result of a switch from fossil fuel to H2,” the study points out.
Hydrogen is a much smaller molecule than methane, so it would leak much more easily from existing natural-gas pipelines if they were used to carry H2, particularly around joints and if they are made from iron, rather than polyethylene or copper.
“Leakage of hydrogen into the atmosphere during production, storage, distribution and use will partially offset some of the benefits of a hydrogen-based economy,” the study explains.
“Minimization of leaks needs to be a priority if hydrogen is adopted as a major energy source."
The report does not consider the GWP of producing hydrogen, only the impact of H2 released into the atmosphere.
A second study, also released on Friday by BEIS, sets out expected hydrogen leakage from the production, transport, storage, and end uses of H2.
The report, Fugitive Hydrogen Emissions in a Future Hydrogen Economy, states that with 99% confidence, electrolysis production of H2 would result in 9.2% of the hydrogen produced making its way into the atmosphere through “venting and purging”, but this would fall to 0.52% “with full recombination of hydrogen from purging and crossover venting”.
The study, commissioned by BEIS and written by Frazer-Nash Consultancy, says that the worst offender for H2 leakage would be tanker transport of liquid hydrogen, with 13.2% of its cargo leaking into the air, followed by above-ground compressed-gas storage (6.52%), fuel cells (2.64%) and refueling stations (0.89%). All other production, transportation, storage, and uses of hydrogen would see leakages of less than 0.53%).
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1067144/atmospheric-implications-of-increased-hydrogen-use.pdf