@am Let’s stick to facts instead of buzzwords, because the economics here aren’t on your side.
- The middle class absolutely does fund the lion’s share of the federal budget.
Here’s the breakdown using IRS and CBO data (these don’t change year to year by much):
• Middle-class and upper-middle-class households (roughly $50k–$500k)
→ Contribute ~51–55% of all federal tax revenue.
• The top 1%
→ Contribute ~26% of federal income taxes, but pay far less in payroll taxes and almost nothing in consumption taxes.
• The bottom 50%
→ Pay 2–3% of total income taxes, but they contribute through payroll taxes, sales taxes, and local taxes, which hit lower incomes the hardest.
When you add up income tax + payroll tax + corporate tax + sales tax + excise tax (the full federal revenue picture), the story is very simple:
👉 The middle class is the tax base of the United States.
Not billionaires.
Not the bottom 50%.
The middle 40–60% pays the bulk of what funds the country.
You don’t get a $5 trillion federal budget off the backs of people making $20k… and you don’t get it off billionaires hiding money in tax shelters either.
- Billionaires don’t “pay the lion’s share”their rate is higher but their effective burden is lower.
The wealthy use:
• stepped-up basis
• pass-through deductions
• preferential capital gains
• carried interest
• corporate write-offs
• offshore holdings
• real estate depreciation loops
• stock-based compensation loopholes
…which means you can have a billionaire with a 3–8% effective tax rate while a middle-class W-2 worker pays 20–30% with no ability to hide or defer anything.
- “Poor people don’t offer jobs” is a made-up talking point.
Jobs are created by:
• consumer demand
• public investment
• infrastructure
• technology cycles
NOT by the personal generosity of the wealthy.
The middle class is the economy. Their spending drives 70% of GDP.
When corporations lay off tens of thousands of them, the economy shrinks.
- Verizon workers are not “the top 10%.”
Let’s do some math:
• Top 10% of the U.S. starts around $190k household, not individual.
• Most Verizon employees (union or management) make $60k–$120k firmly middle class.
• You are closer to the bottom 90% than to a billionaire by a mile.
A billionaire is literally 10,000× richer than someone with a $100k job.
- “The poor don’t pay taxes” is the biggest myth in U.S. politics.
Low-income Americans pay:
• Payroll taxes
• Sales taxes
• Gas taxes
• Property taxes (through rent)
• Fees, fines, tolls, excise taxes
Lower earners often pay a higher share of their income in taxes than the wealthy, because these taxes don’t scale down with income.
- Calling people ‘Marxists’ doesn’t change math.
Nothing you said has anything to do with Marxism, socialism, communism, or any other ideology.
Everything being discussed is basic:
• fiscal math
• tax distribution
• corporate behavior
• labor policy
• wage stagnation vs profits
That’s economics, not “red books.”